Scotland is at a turning point. Some say the union is no longer fit for purpose and it is holding Scotland back. But many people oppose these views saying Scotland needs the rest of the UK and the economic and social factors of independence would be too great to deal with. Independence for Scotland means that we will have the right to make our own decisions about the future of our own country rather than those decisions being made by politicians in London.
In this essay, I will present a fair conclusion by weighing up the arguments for and against Scottish Independence. After many cross-border disputes, including when Scotland was defeated by the English in at Flodden, the Scottish and English crowns we united in when King James IV of Scotland became monarch of the British Isles.
The First Minister of Scotland, Alex Salmond, and the SNP unexpectedly won an historic grand slam — forming the first majority government in the Scottish parliament despite the Scottish system being set up to prevent a party gaining a majority and the only majority government in the whole UK — enabling Mr Salmond to demand an independence referendum.
Moreover independence would enable Scotland to become more successful. One of the main reasons more and more people are supporting Scottish Independence is the great economic benefits it would have. The similarities between Scotland and Norway for example; both having relatively similar populations and large oil, gas and renewable energy resources; show how different Scotland would be if it had control over its own economy.
The British government under Margret Thatcher used the money they made from oil and gas to close down the coal and shipbuilding industries in the s and s which caused widespread poverty and unemployment in Scotland and Northern England while the Norwegian government used the profits they made from the North Sea more wisely to fund a pension fun with?
I would like to take a different angle from it now. In addition, I strongly believe that Britain is arguably structured on extremely undemocratic principles. How is it at all democratic for the UK to have an unequal proportional electoral system in place where nearly seats in parliament are taken up by England and Scotland with 59?
Douglas Alexander on a positive No vote. Because the heart of our story lies as far back as the conundrum of the Scottish Enlightenment; that extraordinary struggle between two views of the human condition. In these letters, as late as , it is revealed that MacDiarmid regarded Hitler and the Nazis as potentially more benign rulers than the British government in Westminster.
But the revelation of ambivalent, even pro-Nazi, sentiments during the Second World War has come as a shock. Supporting our northern allies. We will have the conventional vessels and aircraft based in Scotland to take our responsibilities seriously.
Alistair Carmichael on the Union. Scotland has shown it can go it alone. We may have forgotten some of the rougher edges and harsher words of that debate, and younger people may find it surprising, but whether or not Scotland should have ANY devolved powers was just as heated and controversial a debate as the one we are having now about independence.
Indeed, I sometimes think the only substantive difference is that it took place before the advent of social media. The tartan tax would lead to foreign investors saying no to Scotland. Blair McDougall on the union. I see friends and family with the same hopes and fears as people in Aberdeen, Edinburgh or Glasgow. The jumble of talents, identities, cultures and creativity strengthens us all for being part of it. Tommy Sheppard on voting Yes. For more than two decades, I was an active member of the Labour Party: Much has already been said on the subject; but it is absurd, and dangerous, to reject the stated position of the three UK parties likely to form a future UK government that there will be no sterling currency union.
The UK rejection is not a bargaining chip. Lack of a currency union will cost England, Wales and Northern Ireland additional transaction costs when trading with Scotland, but they will be proportionately a fraction of the costs falling on those living and working in Scotland.
Scotland might adopt the pound unilaterally, but in so doing would lose all control over monetary policy. Class is at heart of vote. The intersection of Westminster and corporations and wealthy individuals is empirically identifiable. For example, Monitor is the name of the group set up to help oversee and enforce the entry of the private sector into the NHS in England.
Companies are dividing up the NHS for private profit, and it is government policy to do so. In the House of Lords, peers linked to companies involved in private healthcare were able to vote on the health bill that opened the way to sweeping outsourcing which McKinsey helped draw up. George Robertson on the Union. It would be a Scottish and indeed global tragedy for it to break up. Isobel Lindsay on the and referendums. The No side has the three Westminster parties, a big initial poll lead, overwhelming print media support and most of big business opinion.
It was a handful of young leftists who decided in to organise a Radical Independence conference and charge for it and some of us were very surprised when people turned up.
This essay was produced by one of our professional writers as a learning aid to help you with your studies. Introduction. Described as Scotland's "biggest choice since " (McLean et al, , p. ix), the upcoming referendum on Scottish independence will provide a pivotal event for the current and future populations of Scotland as voters get the opportunity to decide whether or not they are.
Scottish Independence-Discursive Essay. Scottish Independence - Good or Bad Scotland is at a turning point. The year old Union is some say no longer fit for purpose. Some say it was never designed for the 21st century world and it is well past it's sell by date and is holding Scotland back. The Scottish people voted to move forward.
Essay on Scottish Independence. “The beauty of independence, departure, actions that rely on themselves” -Walt Whitman Currently Scotland is part of the United Kingdom. Scottish Independence is “a political aim for some political parties, advocacy groups, and individuals in Scotland for the country to once again become an independent. Scottish Criminal Justice Scottish criminal justice is a very complicated are of study. There are many different topics of thought that surround the Scottish criminal justice system, in terms of both physical and mental areas.
“The beauty of independence, departure, actions that rely on themselves” -Walt Whitman. Currently Scotland is part of the United Kingdom. Scottish Independence is “a political aim for some political parties, advocacy groups, and individuals in Scotland for the country to once again become an independent sovereign state.”. Essay about Scottish Independence; Essay about Scottish Independence. Words Feb 12th, 5 Pages. Show More. Should Scotland become Independent? Scotland is at a turning point. On 18th September a referendum will be held asking voters a simple yes/no question: “Should Scotland be an independent country?” Independence for.